Inconsistent Results with 0.9.4
Forum rules
An Activity Log is required for support requests. Please read How-to get an activity log? for details on how and why this should be provided.
An Activity Log is required for support requests. Please read How-to get an activity log? for details on how and why this should be provided.
Inconsistent Results with 0.9.4
Hi,
Great tool. Thank you for continuing to develop this.
I've had inconsistent and poor results with 0.9.4 thus far. I don't have a log to post -- for some reason when I call the CLI via dvrmsToolbox it never gets created -- but I have enough trys and fails to roll back to 0.9.3. I don't know if this post will be helpful or not, but I'd figured it would be worth documenting my experience. If you have any suggestions of something to try, I would be happy to do so.
1. When using the "iPhone & iPod Touch" preset, my audio is now out of sync with the video (not so in 0.9.3). Encoding mpeg2 files converted from .dvr-ms; ATSC HD. AMD 5200+ dual core if that matters.
2. The --preset option did not work for custom presets. I created a duplicate of the iPhone preset with a DRC=2 called (AndyiPod), but the app called the default preset instead. When I used "iPhone & iPod Touch" it worked fine (but out of sync, per above).
3. I manually entered values set from 0.9.3 (since presets did not work) but the result was very stuttered video and *slightly* out of sync video.
4. Where did the query option go? I wanted to generate a string instead of the presets (since I could not get presets to work), but it only offered a partial string as far as I could tell.
I'm back and fine with 0.9.3, but the speed improvements are so great in the current version I would like to get the above resolved, if possible. Thanks!
Great tool. Thank you for continuing to develop this.
I've had inconsistent and poor results with 0.9.4 thus far. I don't have a log to post -- for some reason when I call the CLI via dvrmsToolbox it never gets created -- but I have enough trys and fails to roll back to 0.9.3. I don't know if this post will be helpful or not, but I'd figured it would be worth documenting my experience. If you have any suggestions of something to try, I would be happy to do so.
1. When using the "iPhone & iPod Touch" preset, my audio is now out of sync with the video (not so in 0.9.3). Encoding mpeg2 files converted from .dvr-ms; ATSC HD. AMD 5200+ dual core if that matters.
2. The --preset option did not work for custom presets. I created a duplicate of the iPhone preset with a DRC=2 called (AndyiPod), but the app called the default preset instead. When I used "iPhone & iPod Touch" it worked fine (but out of sync, per above).
3. I manually entered values set from 0.9.3 (since presets did not work) but the result was very stuttered video and *slightly* out of sync video.
4. Where did the query option go? I wanted to generate a string instead of the presets (since I could not get presets to work), but it only offered a partial string as far as I could tell.
I'm back and fine with 0.9.3, but the speed improvements are so great in the current version I would like to get the above resolved, if possible. Thanks!
Re: Inconsistent Results with 0.9.4
2. Never has. --Preset is for built-in persets only. The CLI does not have the ability to parse the WinGui's user preset file.
3. Query editor is off by default. You can turn it on in options. It generates a full query minus the executable name.
Everything else needs a log. The CLI uses standard output/error so you have to pipe this to a file if you want an actual log file.
Append: > file.txt 2>&1 to the end. You'll get a blank CLI window, but the contents will be in the file.
3. Query editor is off by default. You can turn it on in options. It generates a full query minus the executable name.
Everything else needs a log. The CLI uses standard output/error so you have to pipe this to a file if you want an actual log file.
Append: > file.txt 2>&1 to the end. You'll get a blank CLI window, but the contents will be in the file.
Re: Inconsistent Results with 0.9.4
Got it, thanks. Overlooked the query tab option -- sorry about that. I'm encoding now and will upload a log shortly.
Re: Inconsistent Results with 0.9.4
Log for audio sync issue:
http://handbrake.fr/pastebin/pastebin.php?show=1009
Let me know if you need anything else.
http://handbrake.fr/pastebin/pastebin.php?show=1009
Let me know if you need anything else.
Re: Inconsistent Results with 0.9.4
The same source file encodes in sync in 0.9.3? Because your log indicates there are problems with the source file.
Re: Inconsistent Results with 0.9.4
Correct. No issues under 0.9.3. I've been using the previous version for 8+ months issue free. FWIW, the process is:
1. DVR-MS fie recorded via Visa Media Center
2. Convert DVR-MS > Commercial-Free DVR-MS
3. Convert Commercial-Free DVR-MS to MPEG
4. Convert MPEG to MP4 via Handbrake
All of this is processed using dvrmsToolbox. Flawless with 0.9.3.
1. DVR-MS fie recorded via Visa Media Center
2. Convert DVR-MS > Commercial-Free DVR-MS
3. Convert Commercial-Free DVR-MS to MPEG
4. Convert MPEG to MP4 via Handbrake
All of this is processed using dvrmsToolbox. Flawless with 0.9.3.
Re: Inconsistent Results with 0.9.4
Could you please provide a log of a successful encode of the same source with 0.9.3 for comparison?ACraigL wrote:Correct. No issues under 0.9.3. I've been using the previous version for 8+ months issue free. FWIW, the process is:
1. DVR-MS fie recorded via Visa Media Center
2. Convert DVR-MS > Commercial-Free DVR-MS
3. Convert Commercial-Free DVR-MS to MPEG
4. Convert MPEG to MP4 via Handbrake
All of this is processed using dvrmsToolbox. Flawless with 0.9.3.
Re: Inconsistent Results with 0.9.4
Here's an 0.9.3 log with the same source:
http://handbrake.fr/pastebin/pastebin.php?show=1012
http://handbrake.fr/pastebin/pastebin.php?show=1012
Re: Inconsistent Results with 0.9.4
A short sample of a source demonstrating this issue could be helpful.
Re: Inconsistent Results with 0.9.4
I can try to upload something this evening, but this is currently a 22-minute show. If I alter it, it may affect the test.
Was there anything worth noting in the new log?
Was there anything worth noting in the new log?
Re: Inconsistent Results with 0.9.4
Sorry to dig up this old thread, but I finally got it working. The change was to make the framerate 29.97. It defaulted to same as source in the iPhone profilem but once I changed this setting, the audio became sync'd wth the video. Happy days! Thanks again for a great tool!
-
- Enlightened
- Posts: 134
- Joined: Mon Jan 04, 2010 2:00 pm
Re: Inconsistent Results with 0.9.4
Is that 2, or even 3, encoding processes I see?ACraigL wrote:Correct. No issues under 0.9.3. I've been using the previous version for 8+ months issue free. FWIW, the process is:
1. DVR-MS fie recorded via Visa Media Center
2. Convert DVR-MS > Commercial-Free DVR-MS
3. Convert Commercial-Free DVR-MS to MPEG
4. Convert MPEG to MP4 via Handbrake
Re: Inconsistent Results with 0.9.4
Not necessarily. Steps 2 and 3 likely only involve remuxing, not transcoding.creamyhorror wrote:Is that 2, or even 3, encoding processes I see?ACraigL wrote:Correct. No issues under 0.9.3. I've been using the previous version for 8+ months issue free. FWIW, the process is:
1. DVR-MS fie recorded via Visa Media Center
2. Convert DVR-MS > Commercial-Free DVR-MS
3. Convert Commercial-Free DVR-MS to MPEG
4. Convert MPEG to MP4 via Handbrake