Encode plays chapters in incorrect order

HandBrake for Mac support
Forum rules
An Activity Log is required for support requests. Please read How-to get an activity log? for details on how and why this should be provided.
PR Buick
Posts: 2
Joined: Fri Nov 21, 2008 1:05 am

Encode plays chapters in incorrect order

Post by PR Buick »

I've tried various searches to solve this but haven't had much luck. A DVD I just purchased (Wall-E) just doesn't seem to encode correctly. It plays the opening company logos, then skips ahead several chapters (which seem to be tacked on to the end.) I'm running OS 10.5.5 and Handbrake Version 0.9.2 (2008021900). Thanks for any help!

Code: Select all

S discontinuity second (current buffer start=16834405, next buffer start=207648030)
[17:26:50] Sync: Audio joined Video after discontinuity at PTS 207645447
[17:26:51] dvd: End of Cell (70) at block 1072290
[17:26:52] dvd: Beginning of Cell (71) at block 1503527
[17:26:52] a52_syncinfo failed
[17:26:52] a52_syncinfo ok
[17:26:52] Sync: Audio discontinuity (sequence: vid 1247664 aud 1247702) (pts 294695607 < 294785607 < 294875607)
[17:26:52] Sync: Video PTS discontinuity second (current buffer start=207958839, next buffer start=294810105)
[17:26:52] Sync: Audio joined Video after discontinuity at PTS 294808647
[17:26:55] dvd: End of Cell (71) at block 1506215
[17:26:56] dvd: Beginning of Cell (72) at block 1444464
[17:26:56] a52_syncinfo failed
[17:26:56] a52_syncinfo ok
[17:26:56] Sync: Audio discontinuity (sequence: vid 1250543 aud 1250598) (pts 282308727 < 282398727 < 282488727)
[17:26:56] Sync: Video PTS discontinuity second (current buffer start=295377671, next buffer start=282422730)
[17:26:56] Sync: Audio joined Video after discontinuity at PTS 282427527
[17:27:01] dvd: End of Cell (72) at block 1448274
[17:27:01] dvd: Beginning of Cell (73) at block 1288360
[17:27:01] a52_syncinfo failed
[17:27:01] a52_syncinfo ok
[17:27:01] Sync: Audio discontinuity (sequence: vid 1254370 aud 1254415) (pts 250646007 < 250736007 < 250826007)
[17:27:01] Sync: Video PTS discontinuity second (current buffer start=283275581, next buffer start=250753092)
[17:27:02] Sync: Audio joined Video after discontinuity at PTS 250759047
[17:27:08] dvd: End of Cell (73) at block 1294050
[17:27:08] dvd: Beginning of Cell (74) at block 1039393
[17:27:08] a52_syncinfo failed
[17:27:08] a52_syncinfo ok
[17:27:08] Sync: Audio discontinuity (sequence: vid 1259949 aud 1260004) (pts 200824887 < 200914887 < 201004887)
[17:27:08] Sync: Video PTS discontinuity second (current buffer start=252011347, next buffer start=200948337)
[17:27:09] Sync: Audio joined Video after discontinuity at PTS 200940807
[17:27:09] Sync: Audio PTS (200940807) < Video PTS (200957892) by greater than 100ms, trashing audio to reconverge
[17:27:09] Sync: Audio back in Sync at PTS 200949447
[17:27:44] dvd: End of Cell (74) at block 1070797
[17:27:44] dvd: Beginning of Cell (75) at block 273547
[17:27:44] a52_syncinfo failed
[17:27:44] a52_syncinfo ok
[17:27:44] Sync: Audio discontinuity (sequence: vid 1289628 aud 1289653) (pts 50186487 < 50276487 < 50366487)
[17:27:44] Sync: Video PTS discontinuity second (current buffer start=207645025, next buffer start=50305845)
[17:27:45] Sync: Audio joined Video after discontinuity at PTS 50313927
[17:27:47] dvd: End of Cell (75) at block 276181
[17:27:47] dvd: Beginning of Cell (76) at block 1029392
[17:27:47] a52_syncinfo failed
[17:27:47] a52_syncinfo ok
[17:27:48] Sync: Audio discontinuity (sequence: vid 1292392 aud 1292434) (pts 198713847 < 198803847 < 198893847)
[17:27:48] Sync: Video PTS discontinuity second (current buffer start=50888425, next buffer start=198834225)
[17:27:48] Sync: Audio joined Video after discontinuity at PTS 198829767
[17:27:48] Sync: Audio PTS (198829767) < Video PTS (198849834) by greater than 100ms, trashing audio to reconverge
[17:27:48] Sync: Audio back in Sync at PTS 198841287
[17:27:48] dvd: End of Cell (76) at block 1030297
[17:27:49] dvd: Beginning of Cell (77) at block 953917
[17:27:49] a52_syncinfo failed
[17:27:49] a52_syncinfo ok
[17:27:49] Sync: Audio discontinuity (sequence: vid 1293489 aud 1293514) (pts 184443447 < 184533447 < 184623447)
[17:27:49] Sync: Video PTS discontinuity second (current buffer start=199081971, next buffer start=184554960)
[17:27:49] Sync: Audio joined Video after discontinuity at PTS 184562247
[17:27:55] dvd: End of Cell (77) at block 959074
[17:27:55] dvd: Beginning of Cell (78) at block 1440100
[17:27:55] a52_syncinfo failed
[17:27:55] a52_syncinfo ok
[17:27:55] Sync: Audio discontinuity (sequence: vid 1298657 aud 1298704) (pts 281413047 < 281503047 < 281593047)
[17:27:55] Sync: Video PTS discontinuity second (current buffer start=185464868, next buffer start=281518827)
[17:27:55] Sync: Audio joined Video after discontinuity at PTS 281514567
[17:27:56] dvd: End of Cell (78) at block 1440744
[17:27:56] dvd: Beginning of Cell (79) at block 2360442
[17:27:56] a52_syncinfo failed
[17:27:56] a52_syncinfo ok
[17:27:57] Sync: Audio discontinuity (sequence: vid 1299418 aud 1299636) (pts 75749367 < 75839367 < 75929367)
[17:27:57] Sync: Video PTS discontinuity second (current buffer start=281709516, next buffer start=75858372)
[17:27:57] Sync: Audio joined Video after discontinuity at PTS 75862407
[17:27:57] dvd: End of Cell (79) at block 2361140
[17:27:58] dvd: Beginning of Cell (80) at block 2208437
[17:27:58] dvd: Chapter Break Cell Found
[17:27:58] MPEG2: Chapter Break Cell Found, searching for GOP
[17:27:58] MPEG2: Group of pictures found, searching for I-Frame
[17:27:58] a52_syncinfo failed
[17:27:58] a52_syncinfo ok
[17:27:58] Sync: Audio discontinuity (sequence: vid 1300496 aud 1300547) (pts 45918327 < 46008327 < 46098327)
[17:27:58] MPEG2: I-Frame Found
[17:27:58] MPEG2: Chapter Break Inserted
[17:27:58] Sync: Video PTS discontinuity second (current buffer start=76023536, next buffer start=46041585)
[17:27:58] work Renderer: Copying Chapter Break @ 269740721
[17:27:58] Sync: Audio joined Video after discontinuity at PTS 46037127
[17:27:58] Sync: Audio PTS (46037127) < Video PTS (46064263) by greater than 100ms, trashing audio to reconverge
[17:27:58] Sync: Audio back in Sync at PTS 46057287
[17:29:25] dvd: End of Cell (80) at block 2281826
[17:29:26] dvd: Beginning of Cell (81) at block 2294350
[17:29:26] dvd: Chapter Break Cell Found
[17:29:26] MPEG2: Chapter Break Cell Found, searching for GOP
[17:29:26] MPEG2: Group of pictures found, searching for I-Frame
[17:29:26] a52_syncinfo failed
[17:29:26] a52_syncinfo ok
[17:29:26] Sync: Audio discontinuity (sequence: vid 1369895 aud 1369977) (pts 62400567 < 62490567 < 62580567)
[17:29:26] MPEG2: I-Frame Found
[17:29:26] MPEG2: Chapter Break Inserted
[17:29:26] Sync: Video PTS discontinuity second (current buffer start=60061089, next buffer start=62513040)
[17:29:26] work Renderer: Copying Chapter Break @ 283760977
[17:29:26] Sync: Audio joined Video after discontinuity at PTS 62522247
[17:29:59] dvd: End of Cell (81) at block 2321228
[17:29:59] dvd: Beginning of Cell (82) at block 1334303
[17:29:59] a52_syncinfo failed
[17:29:59] a52_syncinfo ok
[17:29:59] Sync: Audio discontinuity (sequence: vid 1395596 aud 1395672) (pts 259899447 < 259989447 < 260079447)
[17:29:59] Sync: Video PTS discontinuity second (current buffer start=67585104, next buffer start=260017347)
[17:29:59] Sync: Audio joined Video after discontinuity at PTS 260006727
[17:29:59] Sync: Audio PTS (260006727) < Video PTS (260025537) by greater than 100ms, trashing audio to reconverge
[17:29:59] Sync: Audio back in Sync at PTS 260018247
[17:30:13] dvd: End of Cell (82) at block 1347133
[17:30:13] dvd: Beginning of Cell (83) at block 1875912
[17:30:13] dvd: Chapter Break Cell Found
[17:30:13] MPEG2: Chapter Break Cell Found, searching for GOP
[17:30:13] MPEG2: Group of pictures found, searching for I-Frame
[17:30:13] a52_syncinfo failed
[17:30:13] a52_syncinfo ok
[17:30:14] Sync: Audio discontinuity (sequence: vid 1407937 aud 1407991) (pts 366819447 < 366909447 < 366999447)
[17:30:14] MPEG2: I-Frame Found
[17:30:14] MPEG2: Chapter Break Inserted
[17:30:14] Sync: Video PTS discontinuity second (current buffer start=262568394, next buffer start=366927150)
[17:30:14] work Renderer: Copying Chapter Break @ 291384843
[17:30:14] Sync: Audio joined Video after discontinuity at PTS 366920967
[17:30:25] dvd: End of Cell (83) at block 1884625
[17:30:25] dvd: Beginning of Cell (84) at block 2293279
[17:30:25] dvd: Chapter Break Cell Found
[17:30:25] MPEG2: Chapter Break Cell Found, searching for GOP
[17:30:25] MPEG2: Group of pictures found, searching for I-Frame
[17:30:25] a52_syncinfo failed
[17:30:25] a52_syncinfo ok
[17:30:25] MPEG2: I-Frame Found
[17:30:25] MPEG2: Chapter Break Inserted
[17:30:25] Sync: Audio discontinuity (sequence: vid 1416327 aud 1416373) (pts 62170167 < 62260167 < 62350167)
[17:30:25] Sync: Video PTS discontinuity second (current buffer start=368814535, next buffer start=62284812)
[17:30:25] work Renderer: Copying Chapter Break @ 293272980
[17:30:25] Sync: Audio joined Video after discontinuity at PTS 62271687
[17:30:25] Sync: Audio PTS (62271687) < Video PTS (62281765) by greater than 100ms, trashing audio to reconverge
[17:30:25] Sync: Audio back in Sync at PTS 62274567
[17:30:26] dvd: End of Cell (84) at block 2294097
[17:30:26] dvd: Beginning of Cell (85) at block 2062372
[17:30:26] a52_syncinfo failed
[17:30:26] a52_syncinfo ok
[17:30:27] Sync: Audio discontinuity (sequence: vid 1417320 aud 1417368) (pts 16720887 < 16810887 < 16900887)
[17:30:27] Sync: Video PTS discontinuity second (current buffer start=62510036, next buffer start=16837410)
[17:30:27] Sync: Audio joined Video after discontinuity at PTS 16828167
[17:30:27] Sync: Audio PTS (16828167) < Video PTS (16842277) by greater than 100ms, trashing audio to reconverge
[17:30:27] Sync: Audio back in Sync at PTS 16833927
[17:30:28] dvd: End of Cell (85) at block 2063720
[17:30:31] dvd: Beginning of Cell (86) at block 990498
[17:30:31] a52_syncinfo failed
[17:30:31] a52_syncinfo ok
[17:30:31] Sync: Audio discontinuity (sequence: vid 1418841 aud 1418884) (pts 190718967 < 190808967 < 190898967)
[17:30:31] Sync: Video PTS discontinuity second (current buffer start=17149721, next buffer start=190828227)
[17:30:31] Sync: Audio joined Video after discontinuity at PTS 190829127
[17:30:31] Sync: Audio PTS (190829127) >  Video PTS (190817993) by greater than 100ms insert silence until reconverged
[17:30:31] Sync: Audio back in Sync at PTS 190829127
[17:31:18] dvd: End of Cell (86) at block 1029119
[17:31:19] dvd: Beginning of Cell (87) at block 2283113
[17:31:19] dvd: Chapter Break Cell Found
[17:31:19] MPEG2: Chapter Break Cell Found, searching for GOP
[17:31:19] MPEG2: Group of pictures found, searching for I-Frame
[17:31:19] a52_syncinfo failed
[17:31:19] a52_syncinfo ok
[17:31:19] Sync: Audio discontinuity (sequence: vid 1455294 aud 1455336) (pts 60151287 < 60241287 < 60331287)
[17:31:19] MPEG2: I-Frame Found
[17:31:19] MPEG2: Chapter Break Inserted
[17:31:19] Sync: Video PTS discontinuity second (current buffer start=198829720, next buffer start=60260790)
[17:31:19] work Renderer: Copying Chapter Break @ 301812761
[17:31:19] Sync: Audio joined Video after discontinuity at PTS 60258567
[17:31:19] Sync: Audio PTS (60258567) >  Video PTS (60249195) by greater than 100ms insert silence until reconverged
[17:31:19] Sync: Audio back in Sync at PTS 60258567
[17:31:31] dvd: End of Cell (87) at block 2292912
[17:31:32] dvd: Beginning of Cell (88) at block 2088121
[17:31:32] a52_syncinfo failed
[17:31:32] a52_syncinfo ok
[17:31:32] Sync: Audio discontinuity (sequence: vid 1464862 aud 1464886) (pts 22478007 < 22568007 < 22658007)
[17:31:32] Sync: Video PTS discontinuity second (current buffer start=62280306, next buffer start=22600167)
[17:31:32] Sync: Audio joined Video after discontinuity at PTS 22602567
[17:32:25] dvd: End of Cell (88) at block 2132330
[17:32:25] dvd: Beginning of Cell (89) at block 2132733
[17:32:27] dvd: End of Cell (89) at block 2133912
[17:32:27] dvd: Beginning of Cell (90) at block 2184342
[17:32:27] dvd: Chapter Break Cell Found
[17:32:27] MPEG2: Chapter Break Cell Found, searching for GOP
[17:32:27] a52_syncinfo failed
[17:32:27] MPEG2: Group of pictures found, searching for I-Frame
[17:32:27] a52_syncinfo ok
[17:32:27] Sync: Audio discontinuity (sequence: vid 1508209 aud 1508272) (pts 41252727 < 41342727 < 41432727)
[17:32:27] MPEG2: I-Frame Found
[17:32:27] MPEG2: Chapter Break Inserted
[17:32:27] Sync: Video PTS discontinuity second (current buffer start=31368926, next buffer start=41371920)
[17:32:27] work Renderer: Copying Chapter Break @ 312601038
[17:32:27] Sync: Audio joined Video after discontinuity at PTS 41377287
[17:32:27] Sync: Audio PTS (41377287) < Video PTS (41395191) by greater than 100ms, trashing audio to reconverge
[17:32:28] Sync: Audio back in Sync at PTS 41388807
[17:32:28] dvd: End of Cell (90) at block 2185206
[17:32:29] dvd: Beginning of Cell (91) at block 1456340
[17:32:29] Sync: Audio discontinuity (sequence: vid 1509406 aud 1509457) (pts 284822967 < 284912967 < 285002967)
[17:32:29] Sync: Video PTS discontinuity second (current buffer start=41624170, next buffer start=284927232)
[17:32:29] Sync: Audio joined Video after discontinuity at PTS 284933127
[17:32:54] dvd: End of Cell (91) at block 1475984
[17:32:54] dvd: Beginning of Cell (92) at block 2381772
[17:32:54] a52_syncinfo failed
[17:32:54] a52_syncinfo ok
[17:32:54] Sync: Audio discontinuity (sequence: vid 1528015 aud 1528080) (pts 80026167 < 80116167 < 80206167)
[17:32:54] Sync: Video PTS discontinuity second (current buffer start=289101401, next buffer start=80140650)
[17:32:54] Sync: Audio joined Video after discontinuity at PTS 80144967
[17:32:56] dvd: End of Cell (92) at block 2383800
[17:32:57] dvd: Beginning of Cell (93) at block 881178
[17:32:57] dvd: Chapter Break Cell Found
[17:32:57] MPEG2: Chapter Break Cell Found, searching for GOP
[17:32:57] MPEG2: Group of pictures found, searching for I-Frame
[17:32:57] Sync: Audio discontinuity (sequence: vid 1530225 aud 1530258) (pts 169562487 < 169652487 < 169742487)
[17:32:57] MPEG2: I-Frame Found
[17:32:57] MPEG2: Chapter Break Inserted
[17:32:57] Sync: Video PTS discontinuity second (current buffer start=80628636, next buffer start=169675095)
[17:32:57] Sync: Audio joined Video after discontinuity at PTS 169666887
[17:32:57] work Renderer: Copying Chapter Break @ 317514697
[17:34:01] dvd: End of Cell (93) at block 933575
[17:34:02] dvd: Beginning of Cell (94) at block 1981953
[17:34:02] Sync: Audio discontinuity (sequence: vid 1579523 aud 1579548) (pts 1027767 < 1117767 < 1207767)
[17:34:02] Sync: Video PTS discontinuity second (current buffer start=180723131, next buffer start=1146735)
[17:34:02] Sync: Audio joined Video after discontinuity at PTS 1137927
[17:34:40] dvd: End of Cell (94) at block 2014132
[17:34:40] dvd: Beginning of Cell (95) at block 1738415
[17:34:40] a52_syncinfo failed
[17:34:40] a52_syncinfo ok
[17:34:40] Sync: Audio discontinuity (sequence: vid 1610239 aud 1610267) (pts 339972087 < 340062087 < 340152087)
[17:34:40] Sync: Video PTS discontinuity second (current buffer start=7462042, next buffer start=340092342)
[17:34:40] Sync: Audio joined Video after discontinuity at PTS 340099527
[17:34:40] Sync: Audio PTS (340099527) < Video PTS (340116859) by greater than 100ms, trashing audio to reconverge
[17:34:40] Sync: Audio back in Sync at PTS 340108167
[17:34:52] dvd: End of Cell (95) at block 1748118
[17:34:52] dvd: Beginning of Cell (96) at block 2014607
[17:34:52] a52_syncinfo failed
[17:34:52] a52_syncinfo ok
[17:34:53] Sync: Audio discontinuity (sequence: vid 1619559 aud 1619606) (pts 7360887 < 7450887 < 7540887)
[17:34:53] Sync: Video PTS discontinuity second (current buffer start=342119366, next buffer start=7465047)
[17:34:53] Sync: Audio joined Video after discontinuity at PTS 7462407
[17:34:54] dvd: End of Cell (96) at block 2015782
[17:34:54] dvd: Beginning of Cell (97) at block 1281573
[17:34:54] Sync: Audio discontinuity (sequence: vid 1620939 aud 1620972) (pts 249252087 < 249342087 < 249432087)
[17:34:54] Sync: Video PTS discontinuity second (current buffer start=7778859, next buffer start=249359700)
[17:34:55] Sync: Audio joined Video after discontinuity at PTS 249356487
[17:34:58] dvd: End of Cell (97) at block 1284268
[17:34:59] dvd: Beginning of Cell (98) at block 2134195
[17:34:59] a52_syncinfo failed
[17:34:59] a52_syncinfo ok
[17:34:59] Sync: Audio discontinuity (sequence: vid 1623734 aud 1623786) (pts 31267767 < 31357767 < 31447767)
[17:34:59] Sync: Video PTS discontinuity second (current buffer start=249982821, next buffer start=31371930)
[17:34:59] Sync: Audio joined Video after discontinuity at PTS 31372167
[17:35:59] dvd: End of Cell (98) at block 2184158
[17:36:00] dvd: Beginning of Cell (99) at block 1197477
[17:36:00] a52_syncinfo failed
[17:36:00] a52_syncinfo ok
[17:36:00] Sync: Audio discontinuity (sequence: vid 1670816 aud 1670876) (pts 231542967 < 231632967 < 231722967)
[17:36:00] Sync: Video PTS discontinuity second (current buffer start=41368915, next buffer start=231654012)
[17:36:00] Sync: Audio joined Video after discontinuity at PTS 231641607
[17:36:16] dvd: End of Cell (99) at block 1211800
[17:36:17] dvd: Beginning of Cell (100) at block 1212045
[17:36:17] dvd: Chapter Break Cell Found
[17:36:17] MPEG2: Chapter Break Cell Found, searching for GOP
[17:36:17] MPEG2: Group of pictures found, searching for I-Frame
[17:36:17] MPEG2: I-Frame Found
[17:36:17] MPEG2: Chapter Break Inserted
[17:36:17] work Renderer: Copying Chapter Break @ 351249648
[17:37:35] dvd: End of Cell (100) at block 1281289
[17:37:35] dvd: Beginning of Cell (101) at block 1550553
[17:37:35] a52_syncinfo failed
[17:37:35] a52_syncinfo ok
[17:37:35] Sync: Audio discontinuity (sequence: vid 1749491 aud 1749518) (pts 303459447 < 303549447 < 303639447)
[17:37:35] Sync: Video PTS discontinuity second (current buffer start=249355195, next buffer start=303575862)
[17:37:35] Sync: Audio joined Video after discontinuity at PTS 303575367
[17:37:35] Sync: Audio PTS (303575367) < Video PTS (303585672) by greater than 100ms, trashing audio to reconverge
[17:37:35] Sync: Audio back in Sync at PTS 303578247
[17:38:25] dvd: End of Cell (101) at block 1595770
[17:38:25] dvd: Beginning of Cell (102) at block 2016104
[17:38:26] Sync: Audio discontinuity (sequence: vid 1792005 aud 1792029) (pts 7677687 < 7767687 < 7857687)
[17:38:26] Sync: Video PTS discontinuity second (current buffer start=313035310, next buffer start=7783365)
[17:38:26] Sync: Audio joined Video after discontinuity at PTS 7787847
[17:38:26] Sync: Audio PTS (7787847) >  Video PTS (7771320) by greater than 100ms insert silence until reconverged
[17:38:26] Sync: Audio back in Sync at PTS 7787847
[17:38:58] dvd: End of Cell (102) at block 2045213
[17:38:58] dvd: Beginning of Cell (103) at block 22520
[17:38:58] a52_syncinfo failed
[17:38:58] a52_syncinfo ok
[17:38:58] Sync: Audio discontinuity (sequence: vid 1819581 aud 1819605) (pts 3902007 < 3992007 < 4082007)
[17:38:58] Sync: Video PTS discontinuity second (current buffer start=13634710, next buffer start=4011597)
[17:38:58] dvd: End of Cell (103) at block 22601
[17:38:59] Sync: Audio joined Video after discontinuity at PTS 4035207
[17:38:59] dvd: Beginning of Cell (104) at block 1425155
[17:38:59] a52_syncinfo failed
[17:38:59] a52_syncinfo ok
[17:38:59] Sync: Audio discontinuity (sequence: vid 1819729 aud 1819784) (pts 278481207 < 278571207 < 278661207)
[17:38:59] Sync: Video PTS discontinuity second (current buffer start=4191776, next buffer start=278590902)
[17:38:59] Sync: Audio joined Video after discontinuity at PTS 278597127
[17:38:59] Sync: Audio PTS (278597127) >  Video PTS (278564241) by greater than 100ms insert silence until reconverged
[17:38:59] Sync: Audio back in Sync at PTS 278597127
[17:39:00] dvd: End of Cell (104) at block 1426625
[17:39:01] dvd: Beginning of Cell (105) at block 2016104
[17:39:01] a52_syncinfo failed
[17:39:01] a52_syncinfo ok
[17:39:01] Sync: Audio discontinuity (sequence: vid 1821368 aud 1821411) (pts 7680567 < 7770567 < 7860567)
[17:39:01] Sync: Video PTS discontinuity second (current buffer start=278951262, next buffer start=7783365)
[17:39:01] Sync: Audio joined Video after discontinuity at PTS 7782087
[17:39:01] Sync: Audio PTS (7782087) >  Video PTS (7766278) by greater than 100ms insert silence until reconverged
[17:39:01] Sync: Audio back in Sync at PTS 7782087
[17:39:33] dvd: End of Cell (105) at block 2045213
[17:39:34] dvd: Beginning of Cell (106) at block 106628
[17:39:34] a52_syncinfo failed
[17:39:34] a52_syncinfo ok
[17:39:34] Sync: Audio discontinuity (sequence: vid 1848939 aud 1848967) (pts 19379127 < 19469127 < 19559127)
[17:39:34] Sync: Video PTS discontinuity second (current buffer start=13634710, next buffer start=19495065)
[17:39:34] Sync: Audio joined Video after discontinuity at PTS 19492167
[17:39:47] dvd: End of Cell (106) at block 118490
[17:39:47] dvd: Beginning of Cell (107) at block 1072567
[17:39:47] a52_syncinfo failed
[17:39:47] a52_syncinfo ok
[17:39:47] Sync: Audio discontinuity (sequence: vid 1860501 aud 1860541) (pts 207840567 < 207930567 < 208020567)
[17:39:48] Sync: Video PTS discontinuity second (current buffer start=21772839, next buffer start=207963345)
[17:39:48] Sync: Audio joined Video after discontinuity at PTS 207959367
[17:39:48] Sync: Audio PTS (207959367) < Video PTS (207978780) by greater than 100ms, trashing audio to reconverge
[17:39:48] Sync: Audio back in Sync at PTS 207970887
[17:39:55] dvd: End of Cell (107) at block 1078798
[17:39:55] dvd: Beginning of Cell (108) at block 1838488
[17:39:55] dvd: Chapter Break Cell Found
[17:39:55] MPEG2: Chapter Break Cell Found, searching for GOP
[17:39:55] MPEG2: Group of pictures found, searching for I-Frame
[17:39:55] a52_syncinfo failed
[17:39:55] a52_syncinfo ok
[17:39:55] Sync: Audio discontinuity (sequence: vid 1866406 aud 1866451) (pts 359276727 < 359366727 < 359456727)
[17:39:55] MPEG2: I-Frame Found
[17:39:55] MPEG2: Chapter Break Inserted
[17:39:56] Sync: Video PTS discontinuity second (current buffer start=209670548, next buffer start=359389620)
[17:39:56] work Renderer: Copying Chapter Break @ 391230840
[17:39:56] Sync: Audio joined Video after discontinuity at PTS 359395527
[17:39:56] dvd: End of Cell (108) at block 1839574
[17:39:57] dvd: Beginning of Cell (109) at block 1642346
[17:39:57] Sync: Audio discontinuity (sequence: vid 1867627 aud 1867648) (pts 321401847 < 321491847 < 321581847)
[17:39:57] Sync: Video PTS discontinuity second (current buffer start=359671901, next buffer start=321518787)
[17:39:57] Sync: Audio joined Video after discontinuity at PTS 321520647
[17:39:58] dvd: End of Cell (109) at block 1643505
[17:39:58] dvd: Beginning of Cell (110) at block 1385934
[17:39:58] a52_syncinfo failed
[17:39:58] a52_syncinfo ok
[17:39:58] Sync: Audio discontinuity (sequence: vid 1868996 aud 1869008) (pts 270371127 < 270461127 < 270551127)
[17:39:59] Sync: Video PTS discontinuity second (current buffer start=321819085, next buffer start=270485805)
[17:39:59] Sync: Audio joined Video after discontinuity at PTS 270487047
[17:40:06] dvd: End of Cell (110) at block 1392974
[17:40:07] dvd: Beginning of Cell (111) at block 1884887
[17:40:07] dvd: Chapter Break Cell Found
[17:40:07] MPEG2: Chapter Break Cell Found, searching for GOP
[17:40:07] MPEG2: Group of pictures found, searching for I-Frame
[17:40:07] a52_syncinfo failed
[17:40:07] a52_syncinfo ok
[17:40:07] Sync: Audio discontinuity (sequence: vid 1875822 aud 1875870) (pts 368711607 < 368801607 < 368891607)
[17:40:07] MPEG2: I-Frame Found
[17:40:07] MPEG2: Chapter Break Inserted
[17:40:07] Sync: Video PTS discontinuity second (current buffer start=271999317, next buffer start=368819040)
[17:40:07] work Renderer: Copying Chapter Break @ 393325432
[17:40:07] Sync: Audio joined Video after discontinuity at PTS 368824647
[17:41:47] dvd: End of Cell (111) at block 1967094
[17:41:48] dvd: Beginning of Cell (112) at block 2659443
[17:41:48] Sync: Audio discontinuity (sequence: vid 1953218 aud 1953244) (pts 138827127 < 138917127 < 139007127)
[17:41:48] Sync: Video PTS discontinuity second (current buffer start=385464668, next buffer start=138936387)
[17:41:48] Sync: Audio joined Video after discontinuity at PTS 138928647
[17:42:03] dvd: End of Cell (112) at block 2675828
[17:42:04] dvd: Beginning of Cell (113) at block 1365530
[17:42:04] dvd: Chapter Break Cell Found
[17:42:04] MPEG2: Chapter Break Cell Found, searching for GOP
[17:42:04] MPEG2: Group of pictures found, searching for I-Frame
[17:42:04] MPEG2: I-Frame Found
[17:42:04] MPEG2: Chapter Break Inserted
[17:42:04] Sync: Video PTS discontinuity first (current buffer start=143077522, next buffer start=266323647)
[17:42:04] work Renderer: Copying Chapter Break @ 414109946
[17:42:04] a52_syncinfo failed
[17:42:04] a52_syncinfo ok
[17:42:04] Sync: Audio joined Video after discontinuity at PTS 266293767
[17:42:04] Sync: Audio PTS (266293767) < Video PTS (266326981) by greater than 100ms, trashing audio to reconverge
[17:42:04] Sync: Audio back in Sync at PTS 266319687
[17:42:04] dvd: End of Cell (113) at block 1366124
[17:42:05] dvd: Beginning of Cell (114) at block 2481180
[17:42:05] a52_syncinfo failed
[17:42:05] a52_syncinfo ok
[17:42:05] Sync: Audio discontinuity (sequence: vid 1969314 aud 1969354) (pts 100174647 < 100264647 < 100354647)
[17:42:05] Sync: Video PTS discontinuity second (current buffer start=266503827, next buffer start=100290780)
[17:42:05] Sync: Audio joined Video after discontinuity at PTS 100281927
[17:42:05] Sync: Audio PTS (100281927) < Video PTS (100292389) by greater than 100ms, trashing audio to reconverge
[17:42:05] Sync: Audio back in Sync at PTS 100284807
[17:45:06] dvd: End of Cell (114) at block 2656116
[17:45:07] dvd: Beginning of Cell (115) at block 29827
[17:45:07] a52_syncinfo failed
[17:45:07] a52_syncinfo ok
[17:45:07] Sync: Audio discontinuity (sequence: vid 2132875 aud 2132900) (pts 5347767 < 5437767 < 5527767)
[17:45:07] Sync: Video PTS discontinuity second (current buffer start=138287738, next buffer start=5453037)
[17:45:07] Sync: Audio joined Video after discontinuity at PTS 5455047
[17:45:07] Sync: Audio PTS (5455047) >  Video PTS (5420146) by greater than 100ms insert silence until reconverged
[17:45:07] Sync: Audio back in Sync at PTS 5455047
[17:46:17] dvd: End of Cell (115) at block 99125
[17:46:17] dvd: Beginning of Cell (116) at block 2321570
[17:46:17] a52_syncinfo failed
[17:46:17] a52_syncinfo ok
[17:46:17] Sync: Audio discontinuity (sequence: vid 2198560 aud 2198608) (pts 67486647 < 67576647 < 67666647)
[17:46:17] Sync: Video PTS discontinuity second (current buffer start=18304374, next buffer start=67588110)
[17:46:17] Sync: Audio joined Video after discontinuity at PTS 67588167
[17:47:00] dvd: End of Cell (116) at block 2360124
[17:47:00] dvd: Beginning of Cell (117) at block 1348287
[17:47:00] a52_syncinfo failed
[17:47:00] a52_syncinfo ok
[17:47:00] Sync: Audio discontinuity (sequence: vid 2234972 aud 2235038) (pts 262641207 < 262731207 < 262821207)
[17:47:00] Sync: Video PTS discontinuity second (current buffer start=75853866, next buffer start=262750077)
[17:47:00] Sync: Audio joined Video after discontinuity at PTS 262748487
[17:47:18] dvd: End of Cell (117) at block 1365278
[17:47:19] dvd: Beginning of Cell (118) at block 1547693
[17:47:19] dvd: Chapter Break Cell Found
[17:47:19] MPEG2: Chapter Break Cell Found, searching for GOP
[17:47:19] MPEG2: Group of pictures found, searching for I-Frame
[17:47:19] a52_syncinfo failed
[17:47:19] a52_syncinfo ok
[17:47:19] MPEG2: I-Frame Found
[17:47:19] MPEG2: Chapter Break Inserted
[17:47:19] Sync: Audio discontinuity (sequence: vid 2251114 aud 2251154) (pts 302837367 < 302927367 < 303017367)
[17:47:19] Sync: Video PTS discontinuity second (current buffer start=266320642, next buffer start=302948235)
[17:47:19] work Renderer: Copying Chapter Break @ 476973997
[17:47:19] Sync: Audio joined Video after discontinuity at PTS 302947527
[17:47:22] dvd: End of Cell (118) at block 1550273
[17:47:23] dvd: Beginning of Cell (119) at block 597872
[17:47:23] dvd: Chapter Break Cell Found
[17:47:23] MPEG2: Chapter Break Cell Found, searching for GOP
[17:47:23] MPEG2: Group of pictures found, searching for I-Frame
[17:47:23] a52_syncinfo failed
[17:47:23] a52_syncinfo ok
[17:47:23] Sync: Audio discontinuity (sequence: vid 2253771 aud 2253809) (pts 115035447 < 115125447 < 115215447)
[17:47:23] MPEG2: I-Frame Found
[17:47:23] MPEG2: Chapter Break Inserted
[17:47:23] Sync: Video PTS discontinuity second (current buffer start=303571357, next buffer start=115152627)
[17:47:23] work Renderer: Copying Chapter Break @ 477597120
[17:47:23] Sync: Audio joined Video after discontinuity at PTS 115157127
[17:48:40] dvd: End of Cell (119) at block 665493
[17:48:40] dvd: Beginning of Cell (120) at block 2063982
[17:48:40] a52_syncinfo failed
[17:48:40] a52_syncinfo ok
[17:48:40] Sync: Audio discontinuity (sequence: vid 2317521 aud 2317564) (pts 17020407 < 17110407 < 17200407)
[17:48:40] Sync: Video PTS discontinuity second (current buffer start=128424383, next buffer start=17152725)
[17:48:40] Sync: Audio joined Video after discontinuity at PTS 17144967
[17:48:40] Sync: Audio PTS (17144967) < Video PTS (17162265) by greater than 100ms, trashing audio to reconverge
[17:48:40] Sync: Audio back in Sync at PTS 17153607
[17:49:08] dvd: End of Cell (120) at block 2087982
[17:49:08] dvd: Beginning of Cell (121) at block 2185599
[17:49:08] a52_syncinfo failed
[17:49:08] a52_syncinfo ok
[17:49:08] Sync: Audio discontinuity (sequence: vid 2340013 aud 2340041) (pts 41511927 < 41601927 < 41691927)
[17:49:08] Sync: Video PTS discontinuity second (current buffer start=22597162, next buffer start=41627175)
[17:49:08] Sync: Audio joined Video after discontinuity at PTS 41622087
[17:49:34] dvd: End of Cell (121) at block 2208268
[17:49:35] dvd: Beginning of Cell (122) at block 1643803
[17:49:35] a52_syncinfo failed
[17:49:35] a52_syncinfo ok
[17:49:35] Sync: Audio discontinuity (sequence: vid 2361527 aud 2361552) (pts 321701367 < 321791367 < 321881367)
[17:49:36] Sync: Video PTS discontinuity second (current buffer start=46038580, next buffer start=321822090)
[17:49:36] Sync: Audio joined Video after discontinuity at PTS 321802887
[17:51:00] dvd: End of Cell (122) at block 1717346
[17:51:00] dvd: Beginning of Cell (123) at block 1030548
[17:51:00] a52_syncinfo failed
[17:51:00] a52_syncinfo ok
[17:51:00] Sync: Audio discontinuity (sequence: vid 2430861 aud 2430892) (pts 198967287 < 199057287 < 199147287)
[17:51:00] Sync: Video PTS discontinuity second (current buffer start=336153905, next buffer start=199086477)
[17:51:00] Sync: Audio joined Video after discontinuity at PTS 199077447
[17:51:08] dvd: End of Cell (123) at block 1037939
[17:51:09] dvd: Beginning of Cell (124) at block 276520
[17:51:09] dvd: Chapter Break Cell Found
[17:51:09] MPEG2: Chapter Break Cell Found, searching for GOP
[17:51:09] MPEG2: Group of pictures found, searching for I-Frame
[17:51:09] a52_syncinfo failed
[17:51:09] a52_syncinfo ok
[17:51:09] Sync: Audio discontinuity (sequence: vid 2437991 aud 2438021) (pts 50782647 < 50872647 < 50962647)
[17:51:09] MPEG2: I-Frame Found
[17:51:09] MPEG2: Chapter Break Inserted
[17:51:09] Sync: Video PTS discontinuity second (current buffer start=200676565, next buffer start=50891430)
[17:51:09] work Renderer: Copying Chapter Break @ 516647381
[17:51:09] Sync: Audio joined Video after discontinuity at PTS 50889927
[17:52:23] dvd: End of Cell (124) at block 348149
[17:52:24] dvd: Beginning of Cell (125) at block 1448517
[17:52:24] a52_syncinfo failed
[17:52:24] a52_syncinfo ok
[17:52:24] Sync: Audio discontinuity (sequence: vid 2505616 aud 2505643) (pts 283164087 < 283254087 < 283344087)
[17:52:24] Sync: Video PTS discontinuity second (current buffer start=65121144, next buffer start=283278585)
[17:52:24] Sync: Audio joined Video after discontinuity at PTS 283288647
[17:52:32] dvd: End of Cell (125) at block 1456101
[17:52:33] dvd: Beginning of Cell (126) at block 681283
[17:52:33] Sync: Audio discontinuity (sequence: vid 2512900 aud 2512951) (pts 131298807 < 131388807 < 131478807)
[17:52:33] Sync: Video PTS discontinuity second (current buffer start=284922726, next buffer start=131401860)
[17:52:33] Sync: Audio joined Video after discontinuity at PTS 131403207
[17:55:06] dvd: End of Cell (126) at block 822415
[17:55:06] dvd: Beginning of Cell (127) at block 2675918
[17:55:06] dvd: Chapter Break Cell Found
[17:55:06] dvd: End of Cell (127) at block 2675918
[17:55:06] reader: done
[17:55:06] thread b04e6000 exited ("reader")
[17:55:06] Reader has exited early, inserting silence.
[17:55:06] MPEG2: Chapter Break Cell Found, searching for GOP
[17:55:06] MPEG2: Group of pictures found, searching for I-Frame
[17:55:06] MPEG2: I-Frame Found
[17:55:06] MPEG2: Chapter Break Inserted
[17:55:06] Reader has exited early, inserting silence.
[17:55:06] Sync: Video PTS discontinuity first (current buffer start=158245676, next buffer start=45045)
[17:55:06] Reader has exited early, inserting silence.
[17:55:06] sync: got 149015 frames, 149110 expected
[17:55:06] Reader has exited early, inserting silence.
[17:55:06] Reader has exited early, inserting silence.
[17:55:06] Reader has exited early, inserting silence.
[17:55:06] thread b0901000 exited ("AC3 decoder")
[17:55:06] thread b0879000 exited ("H.264/AVC encoder (libx264)")
[17:55:06] thread b0a05000 exited ("AAC encoder (libfaac)")
[17:55:06] thread b07f7000 exited ("Renderer")
[17:55:06] thread b05fb000 exited ("MPEG-2 decoder (libmpeg2)")
[17:55:06] thread b05fb000 joined ("MPEG-2 decoder (libmpeg2)")
[17:55:06] thread b07f7000 joined ("Renderer")
[17:55:06] render: lost time: 0 (0 frames)
[17:55:06] render: gained time: 0 (0 frames) (0 not accounted for)
[17:55:06] fifo_close: trashing 0 buffer(s)
[17:55:06] fifo_close: trashing 0 buffer(s)
[17:55:06] thread b0879000 joined ("H.264/AVC encoder (libx264)")
x264 [info]: slice I:1763  Avg QP:14.44  size: 19379  PSNR Mean Y:49.42 U:50.20 V:50.25 Avg:49.64 Global:48.95
x264 [info]: slice P:147252 Avg QP:17.34  size:  4815  PSNR Mean Y:46.35 U:47.55 V:47.62 Avg:46.65 Global:45.51
x264 [info]: mb I  I16..4: 25.2%  0.0% 74.8%
x264 [info]: mb P  I16..4:  2.6%  0.0%  4.4%  P16..4: 46.3% 21.5%  6.4%  1.6%  1.0%    skip:16.1%
x264 [info]: final ratefactor: 16.31
x264 [info]: SSIM Mean Y:0.9897353
x264 [info]: PSNR Mean Y:46.384 U:47.578 V:47.656 Avg:46.689 Global:45.537 kb/s:956.63
[17:55:06] thread b0901000 joined ("AC3 decoder")
[17:55:06] thread b0a05000 joined ("AAC encoder (libfaac)")
[17:55:06] thread b04e6000 joined ("reader")
[17:55:07] mux: file size, 844437909 bytes
[17:55:07] mux: track 0, 743201961 bytes, 956.63 kbps
[17:55:07] mux: video bitrate error, -2618113 bytes
[17:55:07] mux: track 1, 99414956 bytes, 127.96 kbps
[17:55:07] mux: overhead, 4.14 bytes per frame
[17:55:07] thread b0568000 exited ("muxer")
[17:55:07] thread b0568000 joined ("muxer")
[17:55:07] fifo_close: trashing 0 buffer(s)
[17:55:07] fifo_close: trashing 0 buffer(s)
[17:55:07] fifo_close: trashing 0 buffer(s)
[17:55:07] fifo_close: trashing 0 buffer(s)
[17:55:07] fifo_close: trashing 0 buffer(s)
[17:55:07] fifo_close: trashing 0 buffer(s)
[17:55:07] fifo_close: trashing 0 buffer(s)
[17:55:07] fifo_close: trashing 0 buffer(s)
[17:55:07] fifo_close: trashing 2 buffer(s)
[17:55:07] Freed 2 buffers of size 512
[17:55:07] Freed 0 buffers of size 1024
[17:55:07] Freed 325 buffers of size 2048
[17:55:07] Freed 0 buffers of size 4096
[17:55:07] Freed 0 buffers of size 8192
[17:55:07] Freed 34 buffers of size 16384
[17:55:07] Freed 0 buffers of size 32768
[17:55:07] Freed 66 buffers of size 518400
[17:55:07] Allocated 35438080 bytes of buffers on this pass and Freed 35438080 bytes, 0 bytes leaked
[17:55:07] thread b00c5000 exited ("work")
[17:55:07] thread b00c5000 joined ("work")
[17:55:07] libhb: work result = 0
Last edited by TedJ on Fri Nov 21, 2008 1:58 am, edited 1 time in total.
Reason: Activity logs should be enclosed in [code] blocks.
ohdeafone
Posts: 1
Joined: Thu Nov 20, 2008 11:50 pm

Re: Encode plays chapters in incorrect order

Post by ohdeafone »

I had the same problem. Seems to be some sort of 'cheap' DRM.
jzietman
Enlightened
Posts: 146
Joined: Mon Feb 04, 2008 3:29 pm

Re: Encode plays chapters in incorrect order

Post by jzietman »

Are you trying to encode from the dvd or a ripped video_ts folder? If the former, try using Fairmount and DTOX to rip the disk as per the sticky thread in this forum.

Also, use the latest snapshot (Snapshot 5) rather than 0.9.2. This is just a guess, but Wall-E (obviously) is very new and the old code might not be able to handle it so well.
rhester
Veteran User
Posts: 2888
Joined: Tue Apr 18, 2006 10:24 pm

Re: Encode plays chapters in incorrect order

Post by rhester »

It is some sort of cheap DRM. National Treasure 2 does the same.

Rodney
macguy59
Posts: 2
Joined: Fri Nov 21, 2008 3:05 am

Re: Encode plays chapters in incorrect order

Post by macguy59 »

Just discovered this myself a little bit ago no joy :evil: I will try the latest snapshot with it.
tenstu
Posts: 10
Joined: Fri Nov 21, 2008 2:23 pm

Re: Encode plays chapters in incorrect order

Post by tenstu »

Same here. Latest snapshot does not work - chapters are out of order. Am trying Fairmount/DTOX movie only extraction as we speak - prior to a Handbrake encode for ATV 5.1/AAC, but am not certain I have the correct title set. This is the holdup for me at present. I'd hate to have to try them all!
nightstrm
Veteran User
Posts: 1887
Joined: Fri Mar 23, 2007 5:43 am

Re: Encode plays chapters in incorrect order

Post by nightstrm »

I wouldn't expect the latest snapshot to have any impact on this problem at all... this is a protection issue.

Maybe it's like The Simpsons Movie... you just have to figure out what title is the correct one?
tenstu
Posts: 10
Joined: Fri Nov 21, 2008 2:23 pm

Re: Encode plays chapters in incorrect order

Post by tenstu »

nightstrm wrote:I wouldn't expect the latest snapshot to have any impact on this problem at all... this is a protection issue.

Maybe it's like The Simpsons Movie... you just have to figure out what title is the correct one?

It is not title 2. Not title 53 either. Anyone else trying to DTOX this?
rhester
Veteran User
Posts: 2888
Joined: Tue Apr 18, 2006 10:24 pm

Re: Encode plays chapters in incorrect order

Post by rhester »

I doubt DTOX or anything else is going to help this.

What appears to be happening is that the cells are joined together in the title in intentionally incorrect order, and DVD VM codes are used to jump between them to "reassemble" them properly during DVD playback.

Short of a more complete VM implementation in HandBrake, nothing can be done.

Hey, at least the studios are getting more clever. =)

Rodney
spotkat
Posts: 10
Joined: Thu Mar 29, 2007 5:48 pm

Re: Encode plays chapters in incorrect order

Post by spotkat »

Title 30 is the correct title. However, when you rip it, the audio and video are off by about 1 second. "Easiest" solution would be to rip it at full quality, bring it in to an editor, realign the audio and video, and save it as a new file.

Tried MTR on Title-Chapter extraction on Title 30, but HB doesn't recognize it as a valid title.

Other solutions?
User avatar
JohnAStebbins
HandBrake Team
Posts: 5712
Joined: Sat Feb 09, 2008 7:21 pm

Re: Encode plays chapters in incorrect order

Post by JohnAStebbins »

If you can build mplayer with dvdnav support, it might handle this problem. Mplayer's dvdnav pays attention to the dvd vm codes. To produce a dump of the title

Code: Select all

mplayer dvdnav://1 -dumpstream -dumpfile wall-e.mpg
That assumes you want title 1. Creates an mpg that handbrake should be able to handle.
dynaflash
Veteran User
Posts: 3820
Joined: Thu Nov 02, 2006 8:19 pm

Re: Encode plays chapters in incorrect order

Post by dynaflash »

rhester wrote:It is some sort of cheap DRM. National Treasure 2 does the same.
However FairTox -> HB worked just fine for NT2. Cannot say for Wall-E but I do know its giving dedicated rippers fits. This is really not an HB issue tbh.
macguy59
Posts: 2
Joined: Fri Nov 21, 2008 3:05 am

Re: Encode plays chapters in incorrect order

Post by macguy59 »

spotkat wrote:Title 30 is the correct title. However, when you rip it, the audio and video are off by about 1 second. "Easiest" solution would be to rip it at full quality, bring it in to an editor, realign the audio and video, and save it as a new file.

Tried MTR on Title-Chapter extraction on Title 30, but HB doesn't recognize it as a valid title.

Other solutions?
When I rip Chapter 30 with Handbrake all I get is a very short clip of video. Perhaps I'm setting the parameter wrong? When it asks what chapters to rip I say from 30 to 30
spotkat
Posts: 10
Joined: Thu Mar 29, 2007 5:48 pm

Re: Encode plays chapters in incorrect order

Post by spotkat »

Rip Title 30, not Chapter 30.

UPDATE - If you rip Title 30 in two parts (Chapters 1-15 and Chapters 16-33) individually, the audio and video are aligned properly. You can then use Quicktime or something similar to put them together. Again, rough, but it works.
tenstu
Posts: 10
Joined: Fri Nov 21, 2008 2:23 pm

Re: Encode plays chapters in incorrect order

Post by tenstu »

spotkat wrote:Rip Title 30, not Chapter 30.

UPDATE - If you rip Title 30 in two parts (Chapters 1-15 and Chapters 16-33) individually, the audio and video are aligned properly. You can then use Quicktime or something similar to put them together. Again, rough, but it works.
spotkat - rip using what? MTR or HB (which version of HB)

Thanks
spotkat
Posts: 10
Joined: Thu Mar 29, 2007 5:48 pm

Re: Encode plays chapters in incorrect order

Post by spotkat »

tenstu wrote:
spotkat wrote:Rip Title 30, not Chapter 30.

UPDATE - If you rip Title 30 in two parts (Chapters 1-15 and Chapters 16-33) individually, the audio and video are aligned properly. You can then use Quicktime or something similar to put them together. Again, rough, but it works.
spotkat - rip using what? MTR or HB (which version of HB)

Thanks
0.9.2 Mac... Yet another update... I'm remembering going through this in Ratatouille... Chapter 1 will cause the audio problem. So I ripped Ch 1 only and then the rest of the movie. Ch 1 will have to be fixed, then the two can be pasted together... haven't finished yet though.
tenstu
Posts: 10
Joined: Fri Nov 21, 2008 2:23 pm

Re: Encode plays chapters in incorrect order

Post by tenstu »

spotkat wrote:Rip Title 30, not Chapter 30.

UPDATE - If you rip Title 30 in two parts (Chapters 1-15 and Chapters 16-33) individually, the audio and video are aligned properly. You can then use Quicktime or something similar to put them together. Again, rough, but it works.

NOT sure it is 30... Here's why:

I used AnyDVD in my XP Parallels install to rip "movie only" to a Video_TS folder. Then, I used HB to encode for AppleTV with AAC and AC3. It appears to have worked!

However, HB saw this as Title 39 - which MIGHT be because of the initial rip. Exact time of the movie (Title 39 as seen in HB) is 1h37m19s.

I now have what I was hoping for using the above steps. I sure hope this helps everyone else!

Stu

UPDATE 1: Am copying to my AppleTV now to ensure the DD5.1 made it over and check the chapter order again. Will report back if anything is wrong.

UPDATE 2: HB reports Title 39 as 1:37:19 when reading FROM DVD. This is exactly what I encoded. Why does everyone else online point to Title 30 then? I have a working encode using above steps and Title 39.
UPDATE 3: Video perfect. My receiver via ATV report DD 2.0... not 5.1 DARN!!!! I can confirm that title 39 through Hb rips perfectly but is only DD 2.0.

Can someone figure out how we can get 5.1????????
Derwinator
Posts: 1
Joined: Sat Nov 22, 2008 5:28 pm

Re: Encode plays chapters in incorrect order

Post by Derwinator »

I did the exact same thing - why can AnyDVD rip a disc with sequencing DRM and Handbrake can't????
User avatar
JohnAStebbins
HandBrake Team
Posts: 5712
Joined: Sat Feb 09, 2008 7:21 pm

Re: Encode plays chapters in incorrect order

Post by JohnAStebbins »

Because, as the documentation says, HandBrake is not a ripper. Although it will handle some of the weird things that you'll find on DVD's, it can not handle everything. As with all OSS, it's a work in progress. Adding capabilities like that requires someone with interest in solving the problem to contribute to the project.
tenstu
Posts: 10
Joined: Fri Nov 21, 2008 2:23 pm

Re: Encode plays chapters in incorrect order

Post by tenstu »

Derwinator wrote:I did the exact same thing - why can AnyDVD rip a disc with sequencing DRM and Handbrake can't????

Did you get a full movie for AppleTV with DD 5.1? If so, can you post or PM me the exact steps you took?! I'd really appreciate it!
PR Buick
Posts: 2
Joined: Fri Nov 21, 2008 1:05 am

Re: Encode plays chapters in incorrect order

Post by PR Buick »

tenstu wrote:
spotkat wrote:Rip Title 30, not Chapter 30.

UPDATE - If you rip Title 30 in two parts (Chapters 1-15 and Chapters 16-33) individually, the audio and video are aligned properly. You can then use Quicktime or something similar to put them together. Again, rough, but it works.

NOT sure it is 30... Here's why:

I used AnyDVD in my XP Parallels install to rip "movie only" to a Video_TS folder. Then, I used HB to encode for AppleTV with AAC and AC3. It appears to have worked!

However, HB saw this as Title 39 - which MIGHT be because of the initial rip. Exact time of the movie (Title 39 as seen in HB) is 1h37m19s.

I now have what I was hoping for using the above steps. I sure hope this helps everyone else!

Stu

UPDATE 1: Am copying to my AppleTV now to ensure the DD5.1 made it over and check the chapter order again. Will report back if anything is wrong.

UPDATE 2: HB reports Title 39 as 1:37:19 when reading FROM DVD. This is exactly what I encoded. Why does everyone else online point to Title 30 then? I have a working encode using above steps and Title 39.
UPDATE 3: Video perfect. My receiver via ATV report DD 2.0... not 5.1 DARN!!!! I can confirm that title 39 through Hb rips perfectly but is only DD 2.0.

Can someone figure out how we can get 5.1????????
Thanks for the help, that worked great. After using AnyDVD, I used HB to encode it for iPod-High-Rez--works fine, no audio sync issues or out-of-order chapters.
gts116
Posts: 5
Joined: Thu Jun 19, 2008 11:32 pm

Re: Encode plays chapters in incorrect order

Post by gts116 »

I ripped Ch. 30 with MTR then used HB 0.9.3 with a modified iPod High Rez preset. I up'ed the bitrate to 2000 and added the 2-pass option. Worked perfectly. When I did the same thing with 0.9.2, the audio/video sync was off. My only guess is that 0.9.3 caught the issue and corrected for it.

BTW, I'm using a 1.66GHz Mac Mini with Leopard if it makes a difference at all.
tenstu
Posts: 10
Joined: Fri Nov 21, 2008 2:23 pm

Re: Encode plays chapters in incorrect order

Post by tenstu »

gts116 wrote:I ripped Ch. 30 with MTR then used HB 0.9.3 with a modified iPod High Rez preset. I up'ed the bitrate to 2000 and added the 2-pass option. Worked perfectly. When I did the same thing with 0.9.2, the audio/video sync was off. My only guess is that 0.9.3 caught the issue and corrected for it.

BTW, I'm using a 1.66GHz Mac Mini with Leopard if it makes a difference at all.
What version of MTR and what settings with it?
bdkennedy1
Enlightened
Posts: 123
Joined: Thu Mar 22, 2007 8:29 pm

Re: Encode plays chapters in incorrect order

Post by bdkennedy1 »

VLC defaults to Title 30 when viewing the DVD, so that means that's the one I should rip. I ripped it then removed the 0 cells with DTox and Handbrake encoded it fine. The only thing that sucks is there's 119 chapters instead of the 32 that there's supposed to be.
tenstu
Posts: 10
Joined: Fri Nov 21, 2008 2:23 pm

Re: Encode plays chapters in incorrect order

Post by tenstu »

bdkennedy1 wrote:VLC defaults to Title 30 when viewing the DVD, so that means that's the one I should rip. I ripped it then removed the 0 cells with DTox and Handbrake encoded it fine. The only thing that sucks is there's 119 chapters instead of the 32 that there's supposed to be.
You ripped it using what and with what settings?
Post Reply